Narrated Ibn ‘Abbaas (ra): Ibn ‘Abbaas (may Allah be pleased with him): When the Messenger of Allah ﷺcame [to Makkah], he refused to enter the Ka’bah while there were idols inside it. He ﷺcommanded for their removal and they were removed. They removed the pictures of Prophet Ibraaheem and Prophet Ismaa’eel (peace be upon them) holding arrows in their hands. The Messenger of Allah ﷺsaid, “May Allah fight them. By Allah, they definitely knew that both of them never drew lots by using arrows superstitiously [for the purpose of divination].” Then, he ﷺentered the House, pronounced takbeer in all its corners, and did not offer prayers therein.”.
Commentary :
The Ka’bah is the ancient House of Allah that Muslims revere and respect. Hence, it should be purified from all forms of impurities.
In this hadeeth, ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbaas (ra) reports an incident proving that the Prophet ﷺprohibited hanging pictures and statues in houses, mosques and so on. In the 8th year of Hijrah, the Prophet arrived at Makkah, but he refused to enter inside the Ka’bah while the idols are still therein. He ordered to have them removed so the Companions (ras) emptied the Ka’bah from all idols and removed images depicting Prophet Ibraheem and Prophet Ismaa’eel (peace be upon them) holding arrows in their hands. Before Islam, the people used to draw lots by using those arrows i.e., they would write my lord ordered me to proceed on some of them and on the rest would write “my lord ordered me not to proceed” and in some cases they would write “Go ahead” on some of them and “Refrain” on the other. If one of them wanted to travel or engage in any act, he would draw lots by those arrows and act according to the arrow they would draw. Allah, Most High, says: {And you are prohibited from seeking decisions based on diving arrows. This is grave disobedience.” (Quran 5:3).
The Prophet ﷺclarified that these are false pictures and he even invoked Allah against them, because they knew with certitude that Ibraaheem (peace be upon him) and Ismaa’eel (peace be upon him) never drew lots by using arrows. The Prophet ﷺentered the House only after purifying it from idols and pictures he ﷺuttered takbeer in its corners and its four sides and he did not offer prayers in it.
The scholars reconciliated between this hadeeth and the hadeeth of Bilaal wherein he confirms that the Prophet ﷺprayed inside the Ka’bah. This reconciliation states that the hadeeth of Bilaal takes precedence over its counterpart, because he entered with the Prophet ﷺthe Ka’bah and observed what the Prophet ﷺdid in it, and also because the Ibn ‘Abbaas – the negator – was not present with the Prophet ﷺthere on that day. Not to mention, Ibn ‘Abbaas (ra) attributed his negation sometimes to Usaamah and sometimes to his brother al-Fadl. It has also been stated that the entrance into the House occurred twice; one occasion, he performed prayers therein, while on the other he did not offer prayers therein.
From the benefits that we can also conclude from this hadeeth is learning that whoever enters the Ka’bah, he should say takbeer in its four directions.
This hadeeth shows that scholars and pious and righteous people should refrain from attending the places where falsehood is present and avoid participating in the gatherings of falsehood and transcend himself over that..